Friday, 16 December 2011

Could European Open Data Strategy be a lever for change in Finland?

Institute's Fellow Antti Halonen writes about the European Open Data Strategy and the possibility for change in Finland.
 By the time of writing this, the Parliament of Finland is just about to start to discuss the issue of opening up data of the National Land Survey of Finland (Maanmittauslaitos). The on-going debacle has been arguably the most visible case of open data discussion in Finland up to date.
Case has its roots in the current Finnish government programme, which states that government further facilitates the opening up of publicly funded data sets. In November, the Land Survey announced that it would release all their mapping data in an open and freely re-usable format, thus losing 1,5me in annual sales profits. Opening up of these data sets is, however, expected to release significant social and commercial value, which would eventually exceed that immediate financial loss. Moreover, if completed, the move would be unprecedentedly progressive open data initiative in the scale of the whole Europe. The Ministry of Agriculture has already approved this, but one single department of the Ministry of Finance has reportedly decided to block the initiative.

There are couple of interesting points to be made.

Firstly, as i.e. Poikola has argued, is the question of political accountability: elected politicians have decided to support open data, but unelected officials effectively vetoed against it. Moreover, the civil servants from other ministries and even different departments of the Ministry of Finance appear to back the initiative. There is a possibility that this is mostly a question of power and where it lies: in the hands of accountable politicians or a few individual civil servants, who don’t even want their names in public.

Secondly, there is the wider European framework and how this Finnish case fits it. Vice-president of the European Commission, Neelie Kroes, announced recently the new European open data strategy, which includes a complete revision of PSI Directive 2003 and will supposedly further enhance the status of open data in the Union and its member states. So far the Brussels’ whip has not been strong enough and there have been cases where member states have used several loopholes in the Directive and kept data behind closed doors, or behind the paywall, as is the case in Finland.

Further Brussels-led regulation is not particularly popular idea at the moment, but it will be interesting to see whether the Finnish Land Survey vs. Ministry of Finance case could prove to be a testing point for the new European data initiatives, when they eventually are concretised into a new Directive and new regulations.

Back in the Finnish parliament, the Minister of Finance, Jutta Urpilainen, has promised to take the matter into discussion with her ministry, but in reality’s sake, one must bear in mind that the minister probably has her hands full of Eurozone crisis at this time. There is a strong possibility for a nasty scenario, where open data gets buried under a pile of more urgent matters if the case is left for the ministry to handle by itself. Moreover, it very well may be summer already when the European open data initiative concretises into action and Brussels’ watchdogs can start gazing over reluctant member states, albeit the fact that vice-president Kroes explicitly encouraged member states not to wait for legislative changes but to start to release data immediately.

As civil society actors, we should be able to find potential solutions on how to influence the ministry in this matter, if we truly find open data important enough objective to pursue. It is quite likely that the Land Survey case will be the test of strength for the Finnish Open Knowledge community, which has begun to find itself of late.

Antti Halonen
Fellow at the Finnish Institute in London


Sagheni Sagheni said...

vimax is a herbal medicine devoted to the men, who serves as the vimax canada permanent and extend appropriate in want, quickly and accurately without side effects and with permanent results, vimax asli has been the choice of international consumers. Vimax PiIls already well known parts of the world and is often used by men to increase male virility and maximize the size of the penis, in order to give satisfaction to their partners. obat pembesar penis Vimax has been recognized by scientists the world as an herbal remedy for pembesar penis and how this increase is no longer a secret mighty man, this is extraordinary usefulness fast, mutually agree and permanent.

sulistio imam said...

I really enjoyed some of the information that has been written on this blog, and some of the comments that have been posted! I'll bookmark for a return visit and see the information more useful. I thank you for you have made a huge post informative .. successful greeting umroh ramadhan

Mohammad Moradzadeh said...

در دنیای امروز بلیط هواپیما که در روزهای هواپیما به همین شکل از الی گشت و آژانس های توری با بلیط هواپیما لحظه آخری و هر کدام از آژانس مسافرتی مارکوپولو که یکی از واحد های آژانس ققنوس از آخرین آژانس های آژانس مسافرتی ققنوس که در سالهای اخیر آژانس هواپیمایی تهران در یکی از آژانس ها باشد.

Mohammad Moradzadeh said...

امروزه یکی از رزرو بلیط هواپیما که سخت هم نیست به همین شکل از قیمت بلیط هواپیما و رزرو آن هم آژانس مسافرتی مشهد در روزهای اخیر آژانس مسافرتی اصفهان که یکی از مهمترین اوج سفر و یکی دیگر از اوج سفر ایرانیان در روزهای اخیر آژانس اوج سفر که هر یک از آژانس مسافرتی اوج سفر و در هر وقت که آژانس هواپیمایی اوج سفر و هر حالتی که باشد.

Mohammad Moradzadeh said...

در دنیای امروز آژانس هواپیمایی که می توان با آژانس مسافرتی با همین شکل که می توان ببیط ماهان به همین روش که وجود تور ارزان در اواسط سال جدید تور مسافرتی در اواسط سال جدید هواپیمایی قطر که یکی از بهترین آژانس در این کار هواپیمایی امارات هم همین طور.

Green Michel said...

Adidas Yeezy Boost 350
Adidas Marathon Shoes

Adidas Springblade Shoes

Adidas Harden Boost Shoes
Adidas NMD Shoes

Salomon Shoes
Salomon Speedcross 4
Salomon S-LAB Sense 4 Shoes

ikut numpan gan said...
Jual Obat Aborsi, Klinik Aborsi, Jual Obat Cytotec, Obat Aborsi, Obat Penggugur Kandungan
Jual Obat Aborsi Alsi, Obat Penggugur Kandungan Aman, Jual Obat Aborsi Tuntas, Jual Obat Aborsi Ampuh
Jual Obat Aborsi Cytotec, Obat Aborsi Manjur, Jual Obat Aborsi Asli Ampuh, Obat Penggugur Kandungan Janin